Re: NSAlert boxes ...

Jon Gotow

Oh interesting - it looks like when you call [NSAlert beginSheetModalForWindow:completionHandler:], the alert gets retained by the parent window's attachedSheet property. So you're right, no issues there either. Now that you've brought it up, I have to say I've never worried about the alert being released too early in my code when I use beginSheetModalForWindow - I never gave it much thought because it just worked.

- Jon

On Feb 17, 2020, at 12:54 AM, Graham Cox <graham@...> wrote:

That is the case I’m talking about and no, it works fine even if you don’t “worry” about the lifecycle.

Just alloc + init + autorelease, then beginSheet…. it works, it has always worked since completion blocks were introduced.

It also works for the -runModal case also, you can autorelease prior to that call and that also doesn’t cause a lifecycle issue.

You can certainly “worry” about extending the lifecycle into the completion block if you want, except the unbalanced release will throw a compiler warning. That in itself shows how unnecessary it is to bother with.

TL;DR: Normal rules apply, stop overthinking this! Just because an NSAlert has some unusual asynchronous lifespan doesn’t mean it needs to be treated any differently from any other object you instantiate.

Join { to automatically receive all group messages.